Insight into South Asia

On corporal punishment in schools

Corporal punishment kills Delhi schoolgirl


Eleven-year-old Shanno, who slipped into coma after her teacher made her stand in the hot sun crouching at school two days ago, died in a government hospital here on Friday.
Shanno’s elder sister Sahina, who studies in the same school, said: “The teacher made her stand in a murga position for over two hours in the hot sun and even placed seven bricks on her back. When Shanno asked for water, the teacher kicked her. Her head hit a wall, she began to bleed from the nose.”

Its hard to remain sober after reading news such as these.  But then, yet another outrageous blog is also not going to make much difference.  I was curious and studied the reactions from our leaders.  Of course, Minister Renuka says: “Its a collective failure” and we can see the followup with the commission, counseling etc.  Its the best that can be done from that position, I suppose.  What can the citizens do?  Maybe, this is a time for introspection.

It is common in our society to place discipline, respect-to-elders etc above all other values.  In the cases of children, this discipline is placed above self-respect, dignity, free thought even!  Many parents would agree.  Except on the days, when there are tragedies like this appear on news.  Tomorrow, parents would go back to normal routine and continue to tell the teachers ‘Do whatever it takes to discipline my child.’  We have sayings for everything: “Beating is more effective than brothers even!”  Nonsense.

I recall my school days, with 17-year old students.  One male student, when harassed by the teacher, reacted by putting a black plastic bag on head, and threatened the teacher’s wife with a knife, when she was alone at home.  No kidding!!  In another incident, a 17 year old female hostel student was made to kneel down in the assembly under hot sun, in front of everyone (it was not a co-ed school).  That night, she committed suicide by jumping in the school well.  She knelt down under the well, holding the pipe firmly, to avoid coming up to the surface of the water, in the well.   She was determined to kill herself, and she did succeed.  She won, we all lost!

During these days, in my 6th grade class, corporal punishment was a regular ritual.  Even top-ranking students were daily beaten-up by the teachers by specialized bamboo canes.  Students who cannot recite the sentences as-is in the book, hence even the top-ranking students, were beaten heavily.  The canes were conditioned by oil, and had to be maintained by fastening rubber tubes at both the ends to prevent them from getting torn, while beating the children.  Student’s bodies can recuperate, but canes cannot, you see.  Numerous new students in my class, ran away from the school back to their villages and dropped out.  We lost many Abdul Kalams.  But, we have trained many disciplined text book reciters.[*]

This news is not an aberration.  It is deeply inter-twined in our system.  Of course, parents would spank their kids, once in a while, upon frustration.  But, as long as parents support the corporal punishment in the school/house, no commission is going to help.  Teachers are also parents, after all.  Instead of expressing our surprise/shock whenever these news break out, we, the citizens can do something.  We can come out and hang our head in shame for having endorsed corporal punishment at school and at house, all along.


[*] – For the curious, I am talking about 90s / 80s.


Filed under: Culture, General, , , , , , ,

5 Responses

  1. malarthamil says:

    The teachers have to be taught a lesson on this.

    For many, the teacher represents a role model.

    Only few teachers resort to corporal punishment due to their own inability to teach. This is like an angry husband beating his innocent wife to hide his failure.

  2. anush says:

    i am deeply frustrated on this incident which is not digestable.
    even in this mordern age the teachers have not forgotten the ancient tradition of education system.may be they would have also undergone the same but it is too bad to show their physco minded attitude towards the innocent minded children.

  3. Ronin says:

    She placed 7 bricks on her back!

    I have faced lot of canes as a student! After I grew up, I think now that some of my teachers might have been violent or deranged persons..

    It did not seem bad at that time as everyone got the treatment..I hear it does not happen as much nowadays..Timely post!

  4. koRkai says:

    Which stand point is vikatakavi taking? Obviously, student’s. For, he blames both teachers and the parents. Those who have responded here, seem to have taken the same stand.

    The news was treated with horror, as expected. But ask a teacher, vikatakavi. What does he or she says?

    Admittedly, in treating children, coroporal punishment is not ideal to get the lasting results. But, all teachers would agree that there should be some punishment. The question is one of its type and duration. Whether it is condign or not? Whether the results will come out of it, now or later? It should not be barbarous; nor terrorising the kids. It should be such as to make the child understand that certain behaviour, done in public, is not acceptable.

    We must leave the aforesaid horrifying incident out; and look at the issue in the larger perspective and children’s own interests.

    We also need to look at the social background from which the child comes to school. If it is poor, it is fairly obvious that at home it is not being shown what constitues correct behaviour. It is adrift in society, like a pariah dog; and when it grows up, picks up any behaviour which is alluring. No doubt, attraction of evil is irresistible. Thus we come across, generally, children poor background end up as gangsters. The sordid fact, Mr vikatakavi, is that a slum is the recruiting ground for underworld dons in Indian metros.

    A teacher confronts such children at school. What should she do? She should impart correct behaviour, which necessarily involves some chasterning and condign punishment. It is a social service.

    In sum, punishment per se is not to be derided. Only its nature can be questioned.

    • vikadakavi says:

      > In sum, punishment per se is not to be derided. Only its nature can be questioned

      The nature, here corporal, is the topic.
      Punishment per se, should be derided.
      Correction has to be applauded. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Faces of South Asia


  • 70,786 Since Nov 2008

Cheer for Us

Like Kalugu.com?. Spread the word by linking to us in your site. Use the following code to display our banner:
<a href="http://kalugu.com"><img src="https://kalugu.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/banner4.jpg" border="0"></a>

%d bloggers like this: